Faith Talks: Part 2 The History and Theology of the Early Church; 1-5 Centuries

New World UMCPastor's Blog

First Century: The Dawn of Christianity

The 1st Century AD was a pivotal era that transformed religious, cultural, and political landscapes, especially in Roman and Jewish societies. The period saw the rise of Christianity, beginning with the birth, crucifixion, and resurrection of Jesus Christ. The Roman Empire, under Augustus, experienced a relative peace known as Pax Romana, which enabled cultural and trade exchanges but was also fraught with political upheaval, including the Jewish Revolt in 66 AD that led to the destruction of the Second Temple.

Christ’s teachings significantly influenced a once-small Jewish sect, eventually giving rise to the world’s largest religion. Key texts like the New Testament and Paul’s letters provide theological context and document early Christian struggles.

Empowered by the Holy Spirit’s descent at Pentecost, early Christians spread Jesus’ teachings throughout the Roman Empire, with Paul the Apostle playing a crucial role. By the Century’s end, the Christian Church had established communities in major Roman cities, planting the seeds for its future global expansion.

Main Events and Themes

The Role of the Apostles: The apostles were crucial in the early establishment of the Church; they were the primary witnesses of Jesus’s life, teachings, death, and resurrection. Their firsthand accounts provided the basis for the New Testament and much of Christian doctrine.

The Spread of Christianity: The Roman Empire’s vast network of roads and sea routes, coupled with the Pax Romana, provided an ideal context for the spread of Christianity. The apostles and other Christian missionaries could travel relatively safely and quickly throughout the Empire.

Growth of Christian Communities: During the 1st Century AD, Christian communities emerged in major cities of the Roman Empire like Rome, Ephesus, Corinth, and Thessalonica and in regions like Syria, Asia Minor, and North Africa. They initially met in the homes of followers; these were the first “house churches.”

Christianity and Judaism: Initially, Christianity was considered a sect within Judaism, with Jesus, the apostles, and most early followers being Jewish. The Romans’ destruction of the Second Temple in Jerusalem in 70 AD was a significant event that led to a gradual distinction between Judaism and Christianity.

Non-canonical Texts: Many texts were written in this period that didn’t make it into the official canon of the New Testament but still shaped early Christian thought. These include the Didache (late 1st or early 2nd centuries), a brief anonymous early Christian treatise containing instructions

History and Theology of the Early Church: 1-5 Centuries Bazan 2

for Christian communities (Christian behavior, rituals and sacraments, church leadership, prayer and worship, and community life).

Martyrdom and Persecution: Many early Christians, including apostles Peter and Paul, were martyred for their faith, mostly during sporadic persecutions by Roman authorities. This era of persecution helped solidify early Christian communities’ identity and commitment.

Theological Developments: The 1st Century AD saw the development of key theological concepts, such as the understanding of Jesus as the Messiah, the concept of the Holy Trinity, and the significance of Jesus’s death and resurrection for salvation.

Leadership Structure: In the late 1st Century, we begin to see the emergence of a more structured leadership within the Church, with roles such as bishops, elders (presbyters), and deacons. These roles are mentioned in the New Testament letters of Paul and in other early Christian writings like the letters of Clement and Ignatius of Antioch.

Main characters

Jesus Christ: The central figure of Christianity, Jesus Christ, is believed to be the Son of God and the savior of humanity. His life, teachings, death, and resurrection form the foundation of the Christian faith. His theological contributions include the concepts of salvation, forgiveness, love, and the establishment of the Kingdom of God.

Peter: One of the twelve apostles and a close companion of Jesus, Peter played a crucial role in the early Christian community. He is recognized as the leader of the apostles and the first bishop of Rome. Peter’s theological contributions include his confession of Jesus as the Messiah, his role in the establishment of the Church, and his teachings on faith and repentance.

Paul: Originally a persecutor of Christians, Paul underwent a dramatic conversion and became a prominent figure in the early Church. Through his missionary journeys and letters (epistles), Paul contributed extensively to the development of Christian theology. His teachings encompassed topics such as justification by faith, the role of grace in salvation, the nature of the Church, and the concept of Christian unity.

John: One of the twelve apostles and the author of the Gospel of John, John is known for his close relationship with Jesus. He emphasized the divinity of Christ and the significance of love in Christian life. His writings also include the Book of Revelation, which offers apocalyptic visions and prophetic insights into the end times.

James: Considered to be the brother of Jesus, James played a significant role in the early Christian community, particularly in Jerusalem. He contributed to the development of early Christian theology, emphasizing the importance of faith accompanied by good works. His teachings on the relationship between faith and deeds influenced subsequent Christian thought.

Stephen: As one of the first Christian martyrs, Stephen’s faith and willingness to defend his beliefs set an example of steadfastness and devotion. His martyrdom and his powerful defense of

History and Theology of the Early Church: 1-5 Centuries Bazan 3

the Christian faith before the Jewish religious leaders highlighted the early Church’s commitment to spreading the message of Jesus.

Second Century: The Emergence and Expansion of Christianity

The 2nd Century AD was crucial for Christianity’s evolution from a marginalized sect to a growing religion within the Roman Empire. The faith expanded beyond Jerusalem into key cities like Rome and Alexandria, building on the missionary efforts of apostles like Paul and Peter. This Century marked the rise of Christian apologetics and theology, with Church Fathers like Ignatius of Antioch and Justin Martyr addressing foundational beliefs and combating heresies such as Gnosticism. Formal church structures and roles, including bishops and priests, began to take shape, distinguishing Christianity as a separate religious entity.

Despite facing persecution from Roman Emperors like Trajan and Marcus Aurelius, Christianity continued to grow, often fueled by the martyrdom of its followers. The period was a paradox of persecution and expansion, encapsulated by Tertullian’s phrase, “The blood of the martyrs is the seed of the Church.” The 2nd Century laid the groundwork for the faith’s future global impact, both in its organizational structure and theological foundations.

Main Events and Themes

Apologists: The 2nd Century saw the emergence of Christian Apologists, writers who defended Christianity against criticisms and misconceptions and tried to make it intellectually respectable in a Greco-Roman context. Some of the most notable Christian apologists of the 2nd Century include Justin Martyr, Irenaeus of Lyons, and Tertullian.

Heresies and Schisms: The Church began to experience internal divisions as different interpretations of Jesus’s teachings and the nature of the Godhead emerged. This led to what mainstream Christianity labeled as heresies. Gnostic Christianity, which emphasized secret knowledge as a means to salvation, was one of the most prominent of these. Marcionism, founded by Marcion of Sinope, was another significant movement that rejected the Old Testament and advocated for a strictly Pauline interpretation of Christianity.

Canonization of the New Testament: While the canon of the New Testament wasn’t officially decided until later centuries, the process of recognizing which books were to be considered authoritative and which were not began in earnest during the 2nd Century. Lists began to appear, such as the Muratorian Fragment, which is thought to be the earliest known list of New Testament books.

Further Spread of Christianity: The Church continued to grow and expand its reach throughout the Roman Empire and beyond, with Christian communities being established as far as India (according to some accounts).

History and Theology of the Early Church: 1-5 Centuries Bazan 4

Persecutions: Periods of localized persecutions of Christians continued in the 2nd Century, often sporadic and dependent on local governors. The reasons were complex but often revolved around Christians’ refusal to participate in the state religion and their allegiance to a “foreign” God, which was seen as potentially seditious.

Development of Church Hierarchy and Structure: The Church started to see a more formal structure in its organization during this Century. The three-tiered structure of bishop, presbyter, and deacon became more common, and the role of the bishop as the spiritual and administrative head of a local church started to solidify.

Christian Writings and Theological Development: The 2nd Century saw the creation of many significant Christian writings beyond those included in the New Testament. These include the letters of Ignatius of Antioch, the Shepherd of Hermas, and the Epistle of Barnabas. These texts further expanded and developed Christian theology.

Main characters

Ignatius of Antioch: Ignatius, the bishop of Antioch, was a prominent figure in the early second Century. He wrote a series of letters while en route to martyrdom, addressing various Christian communities. In his letters, Ignatius emphasized the importance of unity within the Church and the authority of bishops. For example, he advocated for the submission of local churches to their respective bishops and warned against divisions and false teachings.

Justin Martyr: Justin was an early Christian apologist who sought to explain and defend Christianity to the wider Greco-Roman world. His works, such as the “First Apology” and “Dialogue with Trypho,” demonstrated the compatibility between Christian beliefs and philosophy. Justin argued that Christianity fulfilled the ancient Jewish prophecies and appealed to reason and logic. For instance, he defended Christian practices such as baptism and the Eucharist as meaningful rituals rooted in the teachings of Jesus.

Irenaeus of Lyons: Irenaeus played a crucial role in combating heresies, particularly Gnosticism, and defending orthodox Christian beliefs. In his work “Against Heresies,” he exposed and refuted various Gnostic teachings while emphasizing the importance of apostolic tradition and the authority of Scripture. Irenaeus defended the unity of the Church under the leadership of bishops and highlighted the continuity of faith from the apostles to subsequent generations.

Clement of Alexandria: Clement, a Christian philosopher and theologian, sought to harmonize Greek philosophy with Christian teachings. In his works like the “Exhortation to the Greeks” and the “Stromata,” he demonstrated the compatibility between faith and knowledge. Clement emphasized the importance of spiritual growth and the pursuit of virtue as integral aspects of the Christian life. For example, he argued that Christians could draw insights from pagan philosophy to enhance their understanding of God’s truth.

History and Theology of the Early Church: 1-5 Centuries Bazan 5

Tertullian: Tertullian, an early Latin theologian, passionately defended Christian beliefs against various challenges. His works, such as the “Apology” and “On the Prescription of Heretics,” addressed theological and ethical issues of his time. Tertullian emphasized the uniqueness of Christianity and its separation from pagan philosophy. He coined the term “Trinity” to describe the triune nature of God and highlighted the ethical demands of the Christian faith.

Origen: Origen, a renowned biblical scholar, contributed significantly to Christian doctrine and scriptural interpretation. His works, including the “De Principiis” and “Against Celsus,” addressed theological questions and defended Christianity against philosophical and pagan criticisms. Origen advocated for allegorical interpretation of Scripture and explored profound theological concepts such as the pre-existence of souls and the ultimate restoration of all things in Christ. However, most of his significant contributions and controversies date to the 3rd Century rather than the 2nd.

Third Century: Christianity in Transition

The 3rd Century AD was a pivotal period for Christianity, marked by expansion, theological development, and intense persecution. As the Church grew within the Roman Empire, it began organizing hierarchically, with bishops gaining prominence and the roots of the Petrine Doctrine emerging (the belief in the primacy of the bishop of Rome). Theological work by early Church Fathers like Origen (such as the pre-existence of souls, the nature of the Trinity, and the tension between free will and divine providence) helped solidify Christian doctrines despite internal disputes, such as the Novatian Schism over the nature of penance and the readmission of lapsed Christians during times of persecution.

The faith faced heightened persecution from emperors like Decius and Valerian, culminating in the Great Persecution under Diocletian. These trials, while brutal, paradoxically fortified the Christian community. The Church’s ethical stances and social support systems made it increasingly appealing to Roman society. This period of growth, doctrinal refinement, and resilience under persecution set the stage for Christianity’s formal recognition in the Roman Empire in the 4th Century.

Main Events and Themes

Increased Persecutions: This was a century of significant and severe persecution for Christians in the Roman Empire, culminating in the Great Persecution under Emperor Diocletian. Christians were required to make sacrifices to the Roman gods or face harsh punishments, including imprisonment, torture, and death.

Development of Christian Theology: Prominent theologians like Origen and Tertullian significantly developed Christian theology during this period, grappling with issues around the nature of God, the Trinity, and the relationship between faith and reason.

History and Theology of the Early Church: 1-5 Centuries Bazan 6

Rise of Christian Monasticism: The 3rd Century saw the rise of Christian monasticism in Egypt with figures like Anthony the Great. This was a new movement of Christians seeking holiness by retreating from society to live in solitude and contemplation.

Controversies and Schisms: This Century was also marked by controversies and schisms, such as the Novatian and the Donatist controversies, both of which centered around the treatment of those who had lapsed in their faith during times of persecution.

The Church and Absolution: Under Bishop Callixtus I, the Christian Church saw the extension of absolution for grave sins, an issue that sparked significant controversy and even led to the election of the first antipope, Hippolytus.

Writings of Early Church Fathers: Many works of early Church Fathers date back to this Century, including those of Hippolytus, Cyprian of Carthage, and Origen. These writings have been influential in shaping Christian thought and doctrine.

Development of Canon Law: Bishop Cyprian of Carthage was instrumental in the development of Church Canon law. He asserted the independence of bishops against the encroachment of others, and his councils made important rulings regarding the readmission of lapsed Christians. Key issues likely covered by early forms of canon law in the 3rd century would have included matters of church governance (the roles of bishops, priests, and deacons), liturgical practices, the handling of heresies and schisms (like the Novatian Schism), and rules for readmission of lapsed Christians, especially given the periods of persecution.

Growth of Christianity: Despite the challenges and persecution, Christianity continued to grow in numbers and influence, with communities like Theonas in Alexandria becoming large and significant.

Main characters

Origen: Building upon his contributions in the second Century, Origen continued to be a significant figure in the third Century. His works expanded on the themes of biblical interpretation and theological speculation. Origen’s “On First Principles” explored fundamental doctrines of Christianity, such as the nature of God, the incarnation of Christ, and the role of the Holy Spirit. He delved into complex theological concepts, including the concept of salvation and the ultimate destiny of the soul.

Cyprian of Carthage: Cyprian, the bishop of Carthage, played a crucial role in addressing church governance and discipline issues during his time. He emphasized the authority of the bishop and the unity of the Church. Cyprian’s writings, particularly his treatise “On the Unity of the Church,” stressed the importance of maintaining the integrity and coherence of the Church in the face of external threats and internal challenges.

Tertullian: Although Tertullian was active in the previous Century, his influence continued into the third Century. He is notable for his development of Latin theological vocabulary and his defense of orthodox Christian beliefs. Tertullian’s writings, including “Apology” and “On the

History and Theology of the Early Church: 1-5 Centuries Bazan 7

Soul,” addressed various theological and ethical topics. He argued for the reality of Christ’s incarnation, the resurrection of the dead, and the existence of the soul. Tertullian’s rigorous defense of Christian morality and his emphasis on the authority of Scripture had a lasting impact on Christian thought.

Hippolytus of Rome: Hippolytus was an early Christian theologian and writer known for his contributions to understanding the Trinity and Christology. His works, such as “Refutation of All Heresies” and “Against Noetus,” engaged with contemporary heresies and defended orthodox Christian beliefs. Hippolytus provided valuable insights into the nature of God, the divinity of Christ, and the relationship between the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

Clement of Alexandria: While Clement was active in the previous Century, his teachings continued to shape Christian thought in the third Century. He emphasized the harmony between faith and reason and advocated for the integration of Greek philosophy with Christian doctrine. Clement’s works, including “The Stromata” and “Exhortation to the Greeks,” explored various theological and ethical topics. He sought to demonstrate that Christianity had a universal appeal and could provide answers to the deepest questions of life.

Gregory Thaumaturgus: Gregory, also known as Gregory the Wonderworker, was a prominent bishop in the third Century. He is often associated with miracles and supernatural events attributed to his ministry. Gregory’s writings, such as the “Canonical Epistle,” addressed pastoral care and Church governance issues. He emphasized the importance of faith and the power of prayer in the Christian life.

Fourth Century: The Turning Point

The 4th Century AD was transformative for Christianity, shifting from a persecuted sect to the dominant religion of the Roman Empire, largely due to Constantine the Great’s ascent and policies like the Edict of Milan in 313 AD. Constantine also convened the Council of Nicaea in 325 AD, which resolved key doctrinal issues like the Arian controversy and produced the Nicene Creed, a cornerstone of Christian orthodoxy.

The era also birthed Christian monasticism, primarily in Egypt, offering an ascetic lifestyle that enriched church spirituality. While the Church gained imperial favor, it faced challenges like an influx of less committed converts and lingering doctrinal disputes, including Arianism and Donatism. During this Century, the New Testament canon also received official recognition through councils like Laodicea and Hippo.

In summary, the 4th Century was a watershed period for Christianity, marked by a transition from persecution to imperial endorsement, significant theological clarifications, and institutional developments, firmly establishing it as a major world religion.

History and Theology of the Early Church: 1-5 Centuries Bazan 8

Main Events and Themes

The legalization of Christianity: One of the most significant themes of the 4th Century was the shift from Christianity being a persecuted faith to becoming a legally recognized and eventually state-sanctioned religion within the Roman Empire. This process started with the Edict of Milan in 313 AD, which granted religious freedom throughout the Empire.

The Councils of Nicaea and Constantinople: The establishment of orthodoxy within the Church was a major theme in the 4th Century. The First Council of Nicaea (325 AD) and the First Council of Constantinople (381 AD) were both seminal in defining the nature of the divinity of Jesus Christ, leading to the Nicene Creed, a core statement of Christian belief.

The rise of Christian Rome: The dedication of church buildings and the transformation of Rome into a Christian city was another key theme. This includes the building of Old St. Peter’s Basilica and St. Paul Outside the Walls.

Christianity becomes the official religion of the Roman Empire: The declaration of Christianity as the official religion of the Roman Empire by Theodosius I was another pivotal moment, cementing the central role of Christianity in the Empire.

The decline of paganism: The 4th Century also marked a significant decline in the practice of traditional Roman religions. Theodosius I’s declaration and enforcement of Christianity as the sole religion of the Empire was a key moment in this process.

Biblical translations and missionary work: The translation of the Bible into other languages, such as Gothic, marked the expansion of Christianity beyond the borders of the Roman Empire.

Asceticism and Monasticism: This Century also saw the rise of Christian asceticism and monasticism, notably in Egypt, where figures like St. Anthony the Great established some of the first monastic communities.

Main characters

Athanasius of Alexandria: Athanasius was a prominent bishop and theologian who played a central role in the theological debates of the fourth Century. He defended the orthodox understanding of the Trinity and the divinity of Christ against the Arian heresy. Athanasius’ writings, particularly his work “On the Incarnation,” explored the mystery of the Word becoming flesh and its significance for salvation. His theological contributions laid the foundation for the Nicene Creed and had a lasting impact on Christian doctrine.

Basil the Great: Basil, the bishop of Caesarea, was a key figure in the development of monasticism and the shaping of Christian spirituality in the fourth Century. His rule of life, known as the “Basilian Rule,” provided guidelines for communal living, prayer, and asceticism. Basil’s theological writings, such as “On the Holy Spirit,” contributed to understanding the Holy Spirit’s personhood and role within the Trinity. He emphasized the unity and equality of the three divine persons.

History and Theology of the Early Church: 1-5 Centuries Bazan 9

Gregory of Nyssa: Gregory, the younger brother of Basil the Great, was a theologian and bishop known for his contributions to understanding the Trinity and the nature of humanity. His theological works, including “On the Making of Man” and “The Life of Moses,” delved into the relationship between God and humanity and the process of human transformation. Gregory explored the concept of theosis, the idea that humans are called to share in the divine nature through union with Christ.

John Chrysostom: John Chrysostom, the archbishop of Constantinople, was a renowned preacher and theologian in the fourth Century. His eloquent sermons earned him the title of “Golden Mouthed.” Chrysostom’s homilies, such as those on the Gospel of Matthew and the Epistles of Paul, addressed various ethical and moral issues, emphasizing the importance of virtuous living and social justice. He sought to bridge the gap between the rich and the poor and emphasized the duty of Christians to care for the marginalized.

Augustine of Hippo: Augustine is arguably one of the most influential figures in the entire history of Christianity. His writings, including “Confessions” and “City of God,” shaped Western Christian thought and continue to be widely studied. Augustine explored topics such as sin, grace, predestination, and the nature of God. He developed a robust theological framework that significantly impacted the understanding of original sin and salvation. Augustine’s writings continue to be foundational for Western theology.

Fifth Century: Consolidation and Expansion

The 5th Century AD was a crucial period for Christianity, marked by theological fine-tuning, political upheaval with the fall of the Western Roman Empire, and geographical expansion.

The Visigoths, a Germanic tribe led by King Alaric, sacked Rome in 410 AD. This was the first time in 800 years that the city had fallen to a foreign enemy, signaling the impending end of the Western Roman Empire. In 455 AD, the Vandal king Genseric sacked Rome, furthering the decline of the Western Roman Empire. By 476 AD, the Roman Empire had collapsed.

Politically, the collapse of the Western Roman Empire moved the Church into a stabilizing role in society, with bishops often assuming civic duties. The Church also became a preserver of literature and knowledge during this tumultuous time.

Key councils like Ephesus in 431 AD and Chalcedon in 451 AD resolved lingering theological controversies, specifically Christological issues such as the nature of Jesus Christ and the title of Mary as “Theotokos.”

Christianity spread beyond the Roman Empire, reaching Germanic tribes in Western Europe through missionaries, extending to India and China via the Church of the East. The monastic movement also evolved, guided by the Rule of St. Benedict, which emphasized a balanced lifestyle of prayer, labor, and study.

History and Theology of the Early Church: 1-5 Centuries Bazan 10

Notable literary contributions from figures like Augustine of Hippo and Pope Leo I further shaped Christian thought, particularly on issues like the nature of God and the authority of the Papacy.

In summary, the 5th Century was a transformative era for Christianity, involving theological consolidation, political adaptation, and geographical expansion, setting the stage for the Christian Church in the Middle Ages.

Main Events and Themes

Fall of the Western Roman Empire: Perhaps the most significant event of this Century was the fall of the Western Roman Empire in 476 AD. This event marked the end of ancient Rome and the beginning of the Middle Ages in Western Europe. The power vacuum left by the fall of the Roman Empire allowed for the rise of new political powers and paved the way for the spread of Christianity.

Barbarian Invasions: The 5th Century was characterized by invasions of the Roman Empire by various Germanic tribes, culminating in the sacking of Rome by the Visigoths in 410 and the Vandals in 455. The migration and invasions of these tribes played a significant role in shaping Europe’s political and cultural landscape in the centuries to follow.

Theological Controversies and Ecumenical Councils: The 5th Century saw the Church wrestling with major theological controversies, leading to the Council of Ephesus in 431 and the Council of Chalcedon in 451. These councils were significant for defining orthodox Christology, particularly regarding the nature of Christ and Mary’s role as Theotokos (God-bearer).

Rise of the Papacy: The 5th Century was an important period for the consolidation of Papal authority. The leadership of figures like Pope Leo I was instrumental in asserting the influence of the Papacy.

Christianization of the Germanic Tribes: The conversion of Clovis I, King of the Franks, to Christianity in 496 was a pivotal event in the Christianization of Western Europe. His conversion led to the subsequent Christianization of his subjects, which in turn had profound implications for the spread of Christianity.

Schism of the Church of the East: The Church of the East experienced a significant schism in 484, leading to a breakaway group that later became known as the Assyrian Church of the East (1552 AD). The primary factors that led to this schism include theological disagreements, cultural differences, and political conflicts. One of the main theological disputes was the issue of papal authority. The Bishop of Rome, who eventually became known as the Pope, claimed primacy and universal jurisdiction over the entire Christian Church. This claim was not accepted by the Eastern patriarchs, who believed in a more collegial model of church governance, with each patriarch having authority within his respective region. Cultural and linguistic differences also played a role. The Eastern Church, centered in Constantinople (modern-day Istanbul), used Greek as its primary language and had a distinct cultural identity. On the other hand, the Western

History and Theology of the Early Church: 1-5 Centuries Bazan 11

Church, with its center in Rome, used Latin and had a different cultural heritage. These cultural disparities and geographical distance contributed to a growing sense of division. Political conflicts further strained the relationship between the Eastern and Western churches. The decline of the Roman Empire in the West and the rise of the Byzantine Empire in the East led to different political realities and alliances. The political disputes between the Pope and the Byzantine Emperor and the competing power structures further fueled the schism.

Main characters

Cyril of Alexandria: Cyril was a prominent theologian and bishop of Alexandria in the fifth Century. He played a significant role in the Christological controversies of his time, particularly in the Council of Ephesus in 431. Cyril defended the orthodox understanding of the Incarnation, affirming the unity of the divine and human natures in Jesus Christ. His writings, such as his famous “On the Unity of Christ,” emphasized the concept of “hypostatic union” and contributed to the formulation of the doctrine of Theotokos, affirming Mary as the Mother of God.

Leo the Great: Leo, also known as Leo I, served as the bishop of Rome from 440 to 461 and played a crucial role in consolidating papal authority and promoting orthodoxy in the Western Church. His famous “Tome of Leo” was instrumental in resolving the Christological controversies of the time, particularly the Council of Chalcedon in 451. Leo emphasized the two natures of Christ, divine and human, united in one person. His leadership and theological contributions established the papacy’s authority and influence and shaped Western Christianity’s development.

Patrick of Ireland: Patrick, known as the Apostle of Ireland, was a fifth-century missionary and bishop who played a pivotal role in evangelizing Ireland and spreading Christianity throughout the island. His ministry was marked by his courageous efforts to confront pagan beliefs and practices, establish Christian communities, and train local clergy. Patrick’s writings, particularly his “Confession,” offer insights into his missionary endeavors and the challenges he faced. His work laid the foundation for the Christianization of Ireland and had a lasting impact on Celtic Christianity.

Gelasius I: Gelasius I served as the bishop of Rome from 492 to 496 and made significant contributions to the development of the Church’s governance and the relationship between spiritual and temporal authority. He emphasized the distinction between the roles of the Church and the state, asserting the authority of the Church in spiritual matters. Gelasius’ teachings, particularly his famous “Two Swords” theory, influenced the relationship between Church and state in medieval Europe and laid the groundwork for the doctrine of the separation of powers.

Theodoret of Cyrus: Theodoret was a theologian and bishop of Cyrus in the fifth Century. He is known for his biblical commentaries, apologetic works, and efforts to reconcile theological differences between various Christian groups. Theodoret played a significant role in the Nestorian controversy and sought to find a middle ground between the extremes of Nestorianism

History and Theology of the Early Church: 1-5 Centuries Bazan 12

and Eutychianism. His writings, such as his “Eranistes” and “Heresy History,” engaged in theological dialogue and defended orthodox Christian doctrine.

Councils and their theological contributions

Council of Jerusalem (50 AD): The council addressed the issue of whether Gentile converts to Christianity needed to follow Jewish customs, particularly circumcision. It affirmed that Gentile believers were not required to adhere to Jewish practices, establishing a significant precedent for the inclusion of Gentiles in the early Christian community. Its decision to exempt Gentiles from adhering to Jewish customs helped pave the way for the expansion of Christianity beyond its Jewish roots and facilitated its growth among diverse cultural groups.

First Council of Nicaea (325 AD): This council profoundly impacted the development of Christian theology and orthodoxy. By affirming the divinity of Christ and his equality with the Father in the Nicene Creed, it laid the foundation for orthodox Christology and provided a definitive response to the Arian heresy. The council’s decisions solidified the belief in Jesus as fully God and fully human, shaping the understanding of Christ in Christianity.

First Council of Constantinople (381 AD): The theological debates surrounding the Holy Spirit addressed in this council contributed to the development of Trinitarian doctrine. The council affirmed the divinity and personhood of the Holy Spirit, further clarifying the understanding of the Trinity as three co-equal and co-eternal persons. This strengthened the foundation of Trinitarian theology and emphasized the role of the Holy Spirit in the life of believers.

Council of Ephesus (431 AD): This council played a crucial role in the formulation of Christological doctrine. The council focused on the Christological controversy surrounding Nestorianism, a heresy that emphasized a division between the divine and human natures of Jesus, suggesting that they exist as separate persons rather than a unified nature in the incarnate Christ. By affirming the unity of the divine and human natures in the person of Jesus Christ, it reinforced the orthodox understanding of Christ’s nature. The recognition of Mary as Theotokos, the Mother of God, also elevated her status in Christian devotion and emphasized her role in the incarnation of Christ.

Council of Chalcedon (451 AD): The decisions of this council had a profound impact on the development of Christological theology. This council addressed the Christological controversies surrounding Eutychianism and Monophysitism. Eutychianism was a heresy that asserted the complete merging of Christ’s divine and human natures into a singular nature, denying the full humanity of Christ. Monophysitism was a heresy that posited Christ’s nature as solely divine, denying the existence of a distinct human nature in Jesus. Chalcedon affirmed the union of Christ’s divine and human natures in “one person, two natures,” known as the Chalcedonian Definition. It rejected extreme views of Christ’s nature and provided a balanced perspective, influencing the future development of Christology in both Eastern and Western Christianity.

History and Theology of the Early Church: 1-5 Centuries Bazan 13

Second Council of Constantinople (553 AD): This council contributed to the ongoing clarification of theological doctrines and the preservation of orthodox teachings. By condemning certain teachings attributed to Origen and reaffirming the orthodox understanding of the Trinity and Christology, it safeguarded the theological integrity of the faith and helped maintain doctrinal unity within the Church. One example of the “certain teachings attributed to Origen” that the Second Council of Constantinople condemned is the concept of apokatastasis. Origen’s teachings suggested the eventual universal restoration of all beings to God, including the redemption of fallen angels and the ultimate reconciliation of all souls with God. This view was considered controversial and outside the boundaries of orthodox Christian belief, as it seemed to challenge the doctrines of eternal punishment and the finality of judgment. The Second Council of Constantinople deemed these teachings as heretical and reaffirmed the traditional understanding of eternal damnation for the unrepentant.

The development of the Theology of Salvation

Early emphasis on Christ’s sacrifice: In the New Testament, the writings of Paul, Peter, and John highlight the foundational belief that salvation comes through the sacrificial death and resurrection of Jesus Christ (Romans 3:24-25, 1 Peter 1:18-19, 1 John 2:2). The early Christian community recognized the significance of Christ’s redemptive work, emphasizing the forgiveness of sins and reconciliation with God through faith in Christ.

Theological reflection on redemption and grace: In the 2nd Century, theologians like Justin Martyr and Irenaeus explored the concept of redemption and the role of God’s grace in salvation. They affirmed the idea that salvation is a gracious act of God, drawing upon the imagery of Christ as the “new Adam” who restores humanity’s broken relationship with God.

The influence of Augustine: In the 4th and 5th centuries, Augustine of Hippo made significant contributions to the development of the Theology of Salvation. His writings, particularly “Confessions” and “On Grace and Free Will,” emphasized the fallen nature of humanity, the necessity of God’s grace for salvation, and the doctrine of original sin. Augustine’s views greatly influenced the Western Christian understanding of salvation.

The Atonement theories: During the early centuries, different theories of the Atonement emerged as theologians sought to explain the significance of Christ’s death. These theories included the Ransom theory, which saw Christ’s death as a ransom paid to Satan, and the Satisfaction theory, which emphasized Christ’s payment for humanity’s debt of sin. These discussions contributed to a deeper understanding of how Christ’s work brings about salvation.

The role of baptism and faith: Throughout the first five centuries, the role of baptism and faith in salvation was a topic of theological exploration. While baptism was seen as a means of initiation into the Christian community and a visible expression of faith, there were debates regarding its relationship to salvation. The necessity of faith in Christ was consistently emphasized, highlighting the personal response required for salvation (Ephesians 2:8-9, Romans 10:9).

History and Theology of the Early Church: 1-5 Centuries Bazan 14

Salvation and Theological Controversies

The theological controversies surrounding Pelagianism, Semi-Pelagianism, and Augustinianism emerged during the first five centuries and contributed to the discussion on salvation.

Pelagianism: Pelagianism, named after the British monk Pelagius, promoted the idea that human beings have the ability to achieve salvation through their own efforts, apart from the grace of God. Pelagius emphasized human free will and denied the concept of original sin. According to Pelagianism, individuals have the capacity to lead morally upright lives and earn their own salvation. This view was deemed heretical by the early Christian community, as it challenged the necessity of divine grace and undermined the significance of Christ’s redemptive work.

Semi-Pelagianism: Semi-Pelagianism arose as a response to Pelagianism. It sought to find a middle ground between Pelagianism and Augustinianism. Semi-Pelagians acknowledged the existence of original sin and the need for divine grace but believed that human beings still possess some degree of free will and initiative in seeking salvation. They argued that individuals take the initial step towards God, and then God responds with His grace. This perspective aimed to balance the roles of God’s grace and human responsibility in the process of salvation.

Augustinianism: Augustinianism, based on the teachings of Augustine of Hippo, offered a robust response to both Pelagianism and Semi-Pelagianism. Augustine emphasized the fallen nature of humanity and the necessity of God’s grace as the primary agent in salvation. He taught that due to the effects of original sin, human beings are incapable of attaining salvation on their own. Augustine emphasized the sovereignty of God’s grace, asserting that it is God who initiates, enables, and completes the process of salvation. He taught that salvation is a gift from God, received by faith and that human efforts alone cannot merit salvation.

These theological movements and debates significantly shaped the understanding of salvation during the early centuries. The rejection of Pelagianism by the Church affirmed the essential role of divine grace and the inability of human efforts to achieve salvation independently. Augustine’s teachings on original sin and the primacy of divine grace have profoundly influenced Christian theology, particularly in Western Christianity.

The Donatist and Nestorian Controversies

In addition to the development of the Theology of Salvation, the early centuries of Christianity were marked by significant controversies, including the Donatist and Nestorian controversies, which had implications for understanding salvation.

Donatist Controversy: The Donatist controversy arose in the 4th Century in North Africa. It centered around the question of the validity of sacraments administered by “unworthy” clergy. The Donatists argued that sacraments, such as baptism and the Eucharist, performed by clergy who had previously renounced their faith during the Diocletian persecution, were invalid. They believed that the Church’s purity and holiness depended on its ministers’ moral character.

History and Theology of the Early Church: 1-5 Centuries Bazan 15

Augustine of Hippo and other theologians countered this view by emphasizing the objective efficacy of the sacraments, independent of the personal righteousness of the clergy. The controversy addressed questions of sin, forgiveness, and the nature of the Church.

Nestorian Controversy: The Nestorian controversy emerged in the 5th Century and centered around the nature of Christ. Nestorius, the Archbishop of Constantinople, taught that there were two distinct persons in Jesus Christ, one human and one divine, and resisted the use of the title “Theotokos” (Mother of God) for Mary. This view, known as Nestorianism, was condemned as heretical. The Council of Ephesus in 431 affirmed the unity of the person of Christ, declaring that Jesus is both fully human and fully divine, without division or confusion of his natures. This controversy had implications for understanding the nature of Christ’s work in salvation and the significance of the Incarnation.

Both the Donatist and Nestorian controversies reflected broader theological discussions and had implications for understanding salvation. The Donatist controversy raised questions about the role of the Church, sacraments, and the relationship between human sinfulness and divine grace. It reaffirmed the belief in the objective efficacy of the sacraments for salvation, regardless of the personal righteousness of the ministers. The Nestorian controversy contributed to the development of Christology and affirmed the orthodox understanding of the hypostatic union— the belief that Jesus Christ is one person with two distinct but inseparable natures, human and divine. This understanding is essential for comprehending the significance of Christ’s redemptive work and his role as the mediator between God and humanity.

These controversies, although challenging and divisive at the time, played a crucial role in forming Christian theology and articulating core doctrines. They contributed to a more nuanced understanding of salvation, Christology, and the nature of the Church, ultimately shaping the theological landscape of Christianity in subsequent centuries.

The development of the Theology of the Trinity

The development of the Theology of the Trinity in the first five centuries involved a deep exploration of Scripture and a series of significant theological and philosophical debates. Early Christian theologians sought to articulate the nature of God, particularly the relationship between the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

In the Scriptures, we find glimpses of the triune nature of God. For instance, the baptismal formula in Matthew 28:19, where Jesus commands his disciples to baptize in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, implies the distinctiveness of the three persons. Similarly, passages like John 1:1-14 and John 14-16 present Jesus as the Word made flesh and the promise of the coming Holy Spirit, hinting at all three persons’ divine nature and involvement.

The writings of influential theologians played a crucial role in shaping the development of the Theology of the Trinity during the first five centuries:

History and Theology of the Early Church: 1-5 Centuries Bazan 16

  • Tertullian, an early Christian theologian from the late 2nd Century, is known for his influential works such as “Against Praxeas” and “On the Trinity.” He emphasized the unity of substance (consubstantiality) of the Father and the Son, defending against modalistic views that denied the distinctness of the persons within the Godhead.
  • Origen, a prominent theologian of the 2nd and early 3rd centuries, contributed significantly to understanding the Trinity. In his works, such as “De Principiis” and “Against Celsus,” he discussed the eternal existence of the Son, his subordination to the Father, and the role of the Holy Spirit in the Godhead.
  • Athanasius, an influential bishop of Alexandria in the 4th Century, played a pivotal role in defending the orthodox understanding of the Trinity against the Arian heresy. His writings, particularly his famous work “On the Incarnation,” passionately affirmed the deity of Christ and his equality with the Father, emphasizing the unity and co-eternity of the three persons of the Trinity.
  • Basil the Great, a bishop in the 4th Century, contributed significantly to the development of Trinitarian theology through his writings, particularly his work “On the Holy Spirit.” He clarified the divinity and distinct personhood of the Holy Spirit, articulating the full equality and co-eternity of all three persons of the Trinity.
  • Gregory of Nazianzus, a prominent theologian and bishop in the 4th Century, is known for his eloquent sermons and theological treatises. His theological masterpiece, the “Five Theological Orations,” defended the divinity of the Son and the Holy Spirit, emphasizing the equality and unity of the three persons in the Godhead. The Council of Nicaea in 325 was a landmark event that addressed the Arian controversy. It affirmed the divinity of Christ, asserting that he is “of one substance (homoousios) with the Father.” This council established the orthodox understanding of the Trinity as a central doctrine of Christianity. Building upon the work of Nicaea, the Council of Constantinople in 381 further clarified the Trinitarian doctrine. It affirmed the divinity of the Holy Spirit and expanded the Nicene Creed to explicitly state the full equality and co-eternity of the three persons of the Trinity. These councils and influential theologians’ writings laid the foundation for the orthodox understanding of the Trinity. They defended the belief in the three distinct persons within the Godhead while affirming their unity in essence. The Trinitarian doctrine became a defining feature of Christian orthodoxy and continues to shape Christian theology, worship, and devotion to this day.